Insider Medical Admissions: Ranking Schools

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Ranking Schools

There’s an interesting Malcolm Gladwell article in the latest New Yorker on the pitfalls of U.S. News and World Report's college rankings. Gladwell's points regarding the deficiencies of a system that tries to be "comprehensive and heterogeneous" and the flimsiness of quality proxies can be applied to medical school rankings as well.

Despite their many shortcomings, however, I do use U.S. News and World Report's medical school rankings on my website because they are more descriptive than alphabetic order in listing where my clients have been accepted.

About Me

Years of candidate selection at Harvard taught me what characteristics comprise a desirable applicant and how even bright candidates make mistakes that undermine their admissions success. I am a practicing Emergency Physician with nine years of experience training medical students, residents and fellows. I won three teaching and mentorship awards while at Harvard. Please see Insider Medical Admissions for the full array of personalized services I offer to clients applying to medical school, residency, fellowship and post baccalaureate programs.

Dr. Finkel thanks David Presser, MD, MPH for his contributions to the content of her blog entries. Dr. Presser is a practicing Emergency Physician who has written several primers for applicants to medical school and Emergency Medicine residency. Dr. Presser is a graduate of Stanford University, UCSF Medical School, the UCLA/Olive View-UCLA Emergency Medicine Residency Program and the Harvard School of Public Health.

Click here for our terms and conditions, which apply to Insider clients and blog readers.